Vital Farms: Matt O’Hayer. How a serial entrepreneur re-branded the egg

How I Built This · 23 Mar 2026 · 1h 08m

What this episode covers

Matt O’Hayer, founder of Vital Farms, explains how he transformed the commodity egg market into a nearly $1 billion brand by focusing on pasture-raised eggs and a stakeholder-centric business model. He details his journey from a series of failed ventures, including a carpet cleaning business and a barter exchange, to becoming a charter boat captain after losing his net worth on 9/11. O’Hayer describes the operational challenges of scaling production to 600 partner farms, securing early distribution with Whole Foods, and differentiating the product through distinctive packaging and branding.

Most relevant to

companies scaling up

Topics

Mentioned

Companies: Vital Farms, Whole Foods, Cisco, Chemco Manufacturing, Stonyfield, Blue Zone Kitchens
Also: NASDAQ

Other shows on the same ground, closest first.

The Startup CPG Podcast20 Jun 2026 · 48m
Founder + Funder: Fundraising, Founder-Investor Fit, and Building the Next Big Breakfast Brand with Emily Groden of Evergreen and Brian Bernstein of Rich Products Ventures
Emily Groden, Founder and CEO of Evergreen, and Brian Bernstein, Principal at Rich Products Ventures, discuss the journey of building Evergreen from homemade waffles into a nationally distributed frozen breakfast brand. They detail the fundraising process, emphasizing the importance of founder-investor fit, operational alignment, and building relationships long before capital is needed. The conversation covers Evergreen's product expansion from mini waffles to pancakes and protein products, as well as the diligence and strategic value provided by a corporate venture fund.
Fundraising & investors Validation & product-market fit
8 chapters
People of Packaging5 Feb 2026 · 46m
339 - Beyond the Dieline ep 1 with Tom Seymour and Jessica Kwon from Moka Energy!
Tom Seymour interviews Jessica Kwon, founder of Jack & Friends Jerky and co-founder of Moka Energy, about her journey from a Cornell food science background to building CPG brands. Kwon details the operational challenges of bootstrapping, including 3 AM kitchen shifts and hand-packing orders after a New York Times feature, and the technical pivot from DIY Photoshop designs to custom-printed packaging via Wagon Design Studio. The conversation highlights the importance of owning manufacturing mistakes with partners like Seymour’s company and the strategic decision to launch Moka Energy with an experienced team to skip early-stage hurdles.
Packaging design Manufacturing partners & offshoring
8 chapters
The Startup CPG Podcast21 Nov 2023 · 38m
#115 Pure Gold Series: Lessons on Iterating from Seth Goldman + Updates on Eat the Change & Just Ice Tea
Seth Goldman, Co-Founder of Eat the Change and Honest Tea, discusses the rapid scaling of his new beverage brand, Just Ice Tea, which has reached $16 million in gross sales and distribution in over 5,000 stores. He details the strategic decision to discontinue the company's first product, mushroom jerky, due to low velocity, and the subsequent packaging redesign of Cosmic Chews to improve consumer appeal. Goldman also covers the company's recent $14 million raise, the upcoming launch of a canned product line, and his leadership philosophy on mental health support and prioritization during hyper-growth.
Scaling production Pricing, margins & unit economics
7 chapters
The Startup CPG Podcast21 Jan 2025 · 30m
#179 - Bootstrap Heroes: Hazard's Hop Water, SWAIR, Gourmend Foods
Host Daniel Scharff interviews Ryan Hansen of Hazard's Hop Water, Carrie Sporer of SWAIR Hair, and Ketan Vakil of Gourmend Foods about bootstrapping their consumer packaged goods brands to six-figure revenues without venture capital. Hansen details scaling a non-alcoholic hop water brand to $500k by targeting golf courses and breweries, while Sporer explains how SWAIR reached $350k in revenue by focusing on fitness enthusiasts and managing co-founder dynamics. Vakil shares how he built Gourmend Foods to nearly $850k in revenue by reformulating low-FODMAP broths and leveraging online sales and dietitian networks.
Starting a product company Pricing, margins & unit economics
5 chapters
The Startup CPG Podcast7 Feb 2025 · 31m
Founder Feature: Ehime Eigbe-Akindele of Sweet Kiwi
Ehime Eigbe-Akindele, founder of Sweet Kiwi, explains how she transitioned from bankruptcy litigation at Citigroup to creating a frozen whipped Greek yogurt brand that launched into Whole Foods. She details the challenges of scaling a frozen product, including an initial rejection due to non-standard packaging and the strategic pivot to a rebrand that highlights the 'Greek yogurt' and 'sweet/tart' profile based on customer feedback. Ehime also discusses managing retail partnerships, avoiding slotting fees through relationship building, and expanding brand awareness via food service channels like hospitals and universities.
Retail, wholesale & distribution Packaging design
6 chapters

The summary, chapters and topics are generated from the episode’s audio by this directory, not written by How I Built This. The episode itself belongs to its publisher.

Vital Farms: Matt O’Hayer. How a serial entrepreneur re-branded the egg

What this episode covers

Most relevant to

Topics

Mentioned

Related episodes from other shows

Founder + Funder: Fundraising, Founder-Investor Fit, and Building the Next Big Breakfast Brand with Emily Groden of Evergreen and Brian Bernstein of Rich Products Ventures

339 - Beyond the Dieline ep 1 with Tom Seymour and Jessica Kwon from Moka Energy!

#115 Pure Gold Series: Lessons on Iterating from Seth Goldman + Updates on Eat the Change & Just Ice Tea

#179 - Bootstrap Heroes: Hazard's Hop Water, SWAIR, Gourmend Foods

Founder Feature: Ehime Eigbe-Akindele of Sweet Kiwi