Policygenius: Jennifer Fitzgerald

How I Built This · 24 May 2021 · 1h 18m

What this episode covers

Jennifer Fitzgerald, co-founder of Policygenius, explains how she and partner Francois de Lame left McKinsey to build an online insurance marketplace, starting with a focus on disability insurance. They initially struggled to raise venture capital, facing rejection from VCs who didn't understand the market, before raising a $735,000 angel round and eventually a $5 million Series A. The company succeeded by leveraging content marketing, building relationships with personal finance bloggers, and creating educational content to drive organic traffic, eventually expanding into life insurance and raising over $100 million in total funding.

Mentioned

Companies
Policygenius, McKinsey, World Bank, Expedia, Kayak, Oscar, Xenefits, Prudential, MetLife, Progressive, Amazon, Netflix
Products
Know It Owl
Also
Peace Corps, Fincon, New York Times

Other shows on the same ground, closest first.

  • The Startup CPG Podcast · 32m

    Oddball's Path From Idea to Funding a Nationwide Target Launch

    Sophia Cheng, Founder and CEO of Oddball, details her unconventional path from management consulting and Bridgewater Associates to launching a fruit snack brand inspired by her childhood in Singapore. She explains how she validated the product through benchtop formulations at farmers markets and pitch competitions before securing funding, ultimately achieving a nationwide launch at Target. Cheng discusses the specific challenges of fundraising as a first-time, minority woman founder in 2023, emphasizing the mental shift from convincing investors to finding aligned partners, and her strategy for managing a cap table with approximately 20 investors in her first round.

  • The Startup CPG Podcast · 48m

    Founder + Funder: Fundraising, Founder-Investor Fit, and Building the Next Big Breakfast Brand with Emily Groden of Evergreen and Brian Bernstein of Rich Products Ventures

    Emily Groden, Founder and CEO of Evergreen, and Brian Bernstein, Principal at Rich Products Ventures, discuss the journey of building Evergreen from homemade waffles into a nationally distributed frozen breakfast brand. They detail the fundraising process, emphasizing the importance of founder-investor fit, operational alignment, and building relationships long before capital is needed. The conversation covers Evergreen's product expansion from mini waffles to pancakes and protein products, as well as the diligence and strategic value provided by a corporate venture fund.

  • The Startup CPG Podcast · 37m

    Founder Feature: Daniela Suarez of iCalm

    Daniela Suarez, co-founder of iCalm Health, explains how she developed a high-potency natural stress relief shot after a stress-induced tumor made her realize existing supplements were too weak or tasted terrible. She details the years-long formulation process, including working with a specialized flavorist to mask bitter herbs like magnesium, and discusses their DTC launch strategy via a private Facebook community and e-commerce. Suarez also shares a painful lesson about being scammed by celebrity Chet Hanks, emphasizing the importance of founder community trust and warning against paying upfront for endorsements.

  • The Startup CPG Podcast · 21m

    Dip Into Paradise with Founder Emily Edwards

    Emily Edwards, founder of Paradise Icing (Emily's Foods), explains how she transitioned from social work to developing a plant-based icing using pea protein. She details her 18-month product development process at the Purdue Food Science Lab, where she overcame initial taste failures to create a shelf-stable, allergen-free product. Edwards discusses her strategy of bootstrapping the business due to difficulties securing venture capital, while leveraging her social work skills for consumer research and transparent brand storytelling. She outlines her current focus on expanding flavor lines, securing retail placements in boutique grocers and schools, and managing early-stage operations with a small team.

  • The Startup CPG Podcast · 45m

    Founder Fundraising Journey: Jesse Konig, CEO & Co-Founder of Jesse & Ben's

    Jesse Konig, CEO and Co-Founder of Jesse & Ben's, details his fundraising journey from a friends-and-family SAFE round to an institutional process, explaining how velocity data and fanatical customers drove competitive FOMO that increased their valuation cap three times in one week. Konig describes the operational pivot of opening a 6,000 sq ft production facility in 2025 to support nationwide distribution at Whole Foods and Sprouts, while co-founder Ben handled the build-out. He emphasizes that fundraising is a full-time momentum game, advising founders to raise more than they think they need to avoid running out of money and to select investors based on back-channel references rather than just curated intros.

The summary, chapters and topics are generated from the episode’s audio by this directory, not written by How I Built This. The episode itself belongs to its publisher.