#135 Recruiting 101 with Peggy Shell, Creative Alignments

The Startup CPG Podcast · 26 Mar 2024 · 1h 06m · Episode 27

What this episode covers

Peggy Shell, founder of Creative Alignments, explains why early-stage CPG companies should avoid traditional contingency recruiting fees (25-30% of salary) in favor of her firm's time-based hourly model. She outlines a DIY recruiting framework for founders, emphasizing behavioral-based interview questions, intentional sourcing to build diverse talent pools, and the critical importance of pay transparency bands to ensure equity. Shell also discusses negotiation strategies, the role of equity in compensation packages, and how to foster an inclusive culture through empathy and clear communication to retain top talent.

Mentioned

Companies
Creative Alignments, Rxbar, Halo Top, Kellogg's, Fourth & Heart, Caulipower, Olipop, Kali Power, Startup CPG, Project Potluck, Jedi Collaborative, Naturally Network, Included
Tools
Gusto, LinkedIn, Indeed, Glassdoor, Salary.com, Cura

Other shows on the same ground, closest first.

  • Embedded.fm · 1h 23m

    265: What's Your Superpower

    Anita Pagin, a generalist recruiter and career coach who recently joined Carbon3D, explains the realities of the recruiting industry, distinguishing between in-house, agency, and freelance roles. She details how top recruiters vet candidates by reading profiles thoroughly rather than sending mass emails, and emphasizes that candidates must be able to explain their technical work in layman's terms to pass phone screens. Pagin provides specific advice on resume formatting, such as using portfolios and avoiding bolded skill lists, and discusses the nuances of salary negotiation, including the trade-offs between base pay and equity in startups versus public companies.

  • The Manufacturing Executive · 48m

    Building A Talent Pipeline

    Jay Veniard, Founder and CEO of Ventech Search Group, explains how manufacturing companies can build talent pipelines and reduce reliance on expensive external recruiters. He argues that CEOs must own the Employee Value Proposition (EVP) and proactively build relationships with passive candidates via LinkedIn personal branding. Veniard also advises rewriting job descriptions as compelling stories with transparent salary ranges to attract top-tier talent who rarely apply through traditional job boards.

  • How I Built This · 37m

    Advice Line: What’s Your Value?

    Guy Raz is joined by former guests Miguel McKelvey (WeWork), Alexa Hirschfeld (Paperless Post), and Pete Maldonado and Rashid Ali (Chomps) to advise three early-stage founders on communicating product value. Megan Downey of Shiki Wrap discusses the trade-off between experiential pop-ups and retail for her reusable gift wrap. Amanda of Woofsie seeks help positioning her deck of dog enrichment cards, while Mark Goldfarb of In Mark's Kitchen asks how to hire for growth without compromising his premium artisanal pesto quality.

  • How I Built This · 48m

    Advice Line with Bill Creelman of Spindrift

    Bill Creelman, founder and chair of Spindrift, joins Guy Raz to answer questions from three early-stage entrepreneurs: Josh Jankowitz of Donna's Pickle Beer, Zach Will of Kona Brand, and Jean-Pierre Terrence of Soma Kombucha. Creelman advises Jankowitz to maintain authenticity with fresh pickle brine to defend against copycats, encourages Will to delay hiring and document his brand voice, and suggests Terrence simplify his four revenue streams to focus on high-margin consulting and wild probiotics. The episode highlights the tension between product integrity and cost, the challenges of scaling without overhead, and the importance of simplification for struggling founders.

  • Oxide and Friends · 1h 45m

    Hiring Processes with Gergely Orosz

    Bryan Cantrill and Adam Leventhal of Oxide Computer Company discuss their hiring process with Gergely Orosz, The Pragmatic Engineer. They explain how Oxide uses a written portfolio and RFD (Request for Discussion) documents to evaluate candidates, prioritizing integrity and clear communication over traditional coding interviews. The founders share how past bad hires at Joyent and Sun led them to design a system that forces transparency and self-reflection, ensuring that every candidate, including founders, undergoes the same rigorous review. They emphasize that this approach helps them avoid 'mishires' and build a team with shared values, even at the cost of being time-intensive.

The summary, chapters and topics are generated from the episode’s audio by this directory, not written by The Startup CPG Podcast. The episode itself belongs to its publisher.