Founder Feature: BJ Howard of Wild West Chocolate

The Startup CPG Podcast · 19 Sept 2025 · 33m · Episode 195

What this episode covers

BJ Howard, founder of Wild West Chocolate, explains how her brand uses a proprietary blend of four dehydrated fruits (mulberry, peach, mango, date) to create no-added-sugar chocolate, launching just as cacao prices spiked 400%. She details the 18-month formulation process with chocolatier Guy Deboss and the strategic decision to target health-conscious consumers seeking a guilt-free indulgence without sugar alcohols or stevia. Howard discusses navigating the volatile cacao market, securing shelf space at Whole Foods and Sprouts, and differentiating the brand through distinctive 'Wild West' branding and regenerative organic certification.

Mentioned

Companies
Wild West Chocolate, Made in Nature, Creative Pack, Whole Foods, Sprouts, Mars, Hershey's, Costco, Fresh Market, Wegmans
Products
Lilies, Hue
Also
Guy Deboss, Doug Brent

Other shows on the same ground, closest first.

  • How I Built This · 1h 07m

    Lily’s Sweets: Cynthia Tice

    Cynthia Tice, founder of Lily’s Sweets, explains how she launched a sugar-free chocolate brand at age 59, leveraging stevia and erythritol to create a product that tasted like traditional chocolate. After securing a national launch at Whole Foods with just four employees, she navigated a costly legal battle with a former partner before partnering with VMG to scale the business. The company was eventually acquired by Hershey’s for $425 million, validating Tice’s prediction that consumers would pay for healthier treats.

  • People of Packaging · 37m

    244 - Jody Polishchuk from Sundays on how they made the first zero sugar creme cookie

    Jody Polishchuk, founder of Sundays, discusses his journey from previous CPG ventures like The Juice Box and Yuga to creating the first zero-sugar creme cookie. He details the extensive R&D process, which involved three co-packers and three R&D teams over three years and $100,000, to replicate the taste of an Oreo without sugar. Polishchuk also explains his strategic decision to launch with a strong, affordable brand identity designed by Christine Brown and Django Jim, rather than spending heavily on a traditional agency.

  • How I Built This · 21m

    How I Built Resilience: Kara Goldin of Hint

    Kara Goldin, founder and CEO of Hint, explains how she launched the unsweetened flavored water brand after quitting diet soda to improve her health. She details the challenges of entering the saturated beverage industry without prior experience, specifically the difficulty of convincing retailers to stock a new category and the technical hurdle of creating a preservative-free product using real fruit. Goldin also discusses how Hint navigated the pandemic by leveraging its automated US-based manufacturing and pivoting aggressively to direct-to-consumer sales, which tripled during the crisis.

  • How I Built This · 1h 26m

    Perfect Snacks: Bill and Leigh Keith

    Bill and Leigh Keith, co-founders of Perfect Bars, explain how they turned their father's homemade peanut butter and honey recipe into a major CPG brand, eventually selling to Mondelēz International. They detail the bootstrapped journey from hand-rolling bars in a Sacramento warehouse to securing deals with Whole Foods and Costco, and the critical decision to introduce a chocolate chip flavor to meet investor metrics. The episode highlights a major crisis when a false positive salmonella test forced a massive recall, nearly shutting down the company before they secured $15 million in investment from VMG Partners.

  • How I Built This · 1h 14m

    SmartSweets: Tara Bosch

    Tara Bosch, founder of SmartSweets, explains how she developed a low-sugar gummy candy recipe in her grandmother's basement and secured debt financing to launch the brand. She details the critical decision to pivot from 'Stevie Sweets' to 'SmartSweets' after investor rejection, and the subsequent challenge of finding a reliable manufacturer after a partner attempted to steal her formula. Bosch describes scaling production, securing a national deal with Whole Foods, and eventually selling a majority stake to TPG for $360 million to accelerate global growth.

The summary, chapters and topics are generated from the episode’s audio by this directory, not written by The Startup CPG Podcast. The episode itself belongs to its publisher.