Hardware Podcasts

#008: Blood In The Water: Americas Assault on Innovation - Kip Doyle - Patent Process, Product Innovation, Defending Patents, Napkin Sketch to Manufacturing

Designing in the Wild · 14 Feb 2022 · 58m · Episode 8

What this episode covers

Kip Doyle, inventor of the Card Shark credit card wallet skin and author of 'Blood In The Water', recounts her decade-long struggle to protect her intellectual property against major tech companies like Speck and OtterBox. She details the transition from a napkin sketch to utility and design patents, explaining how the America Invents Act (AIA) and Inter Partes Review (IPR) processes have made it nearly impossible for independent inventors to defend their rights. Doyle advises creators to document their ideas meticulously, hire local or student lawyers to manage costs, and join communities like USInventor.org for support.

Most relevant to

early-stage companies

Topics

Mentioned

Companies
Speck, OtterBox, Incipio, USInventor.org, Apple, Blackberry
Products
Card Shark, Blood In The Water: America's Assault on Innovation

Related episodes from other shows

Other shows on the same ground, closest first.

  • Product Startup · 37m

    116: How to Turn an Invention into a Product Business

    Tom Gray, founder of Make48 and former Handy Camel executive, explains how inventors can transition from hobbyist to business owner by choosing between licensing or building a startup. He outlines four critical assets for success: a refined prototype, a concise sales video, a one-page sales sheet, and proper IP protection. Gray advocates for a 'stepping stone' manufacturing strategy, using short runs and aluminum tooling to validate the product with real users before committing to expensive steel tooling. He emphasizes that this iterative approach reduces risk and increases the likelihood of securing licensing deals or investment.

    Validation & product-market fitCrowdfunding & preorders
    8 chapters

  • Being an Engineer · 41m

    S1E06 First to file, secrecy, & fast-tracking patents | Tom Galvani

    Tom Galvani, a patent attorney and founder of Galvani Legal, explains the mechanics of securing intellectual property for physical products, emphasizing the critical importance of secrecy before filing. He details the distinction between utility and design patents, the 'first to file' system, and how provisional applications can buy time for startups. Galvani also outlines the costs, timelines, and enforcement strategies associated with protecting inventions in the US market.

    Intellectual propertyCareers & education
    8 chapters

  • How I Built This · 1h 11m

    Square: Jim McKelvey. He Lost a $2,000 Sale, Then Built a $10 Billion Company

    Jim McKelvey, co-founder of Square (now Block), explains how a lost $2,000 glass art sale to a customer with only an American Express card inspired the creation of the Square card reader. He details the engineering hack of using the iPhone's headphone jack to read magnetic stripes, bypassing Apple's restrictive dock connector, and the strategic decision to pitch investors with 140 reasons for failure to build trust. McKelvey describes how this 'innovation stack' of 14 necessary inventions protected Square from being crushed by Amazon's cheaper, copied product in 2014, allowing the company to thrive despite regulatory hurdles and legal disputes.

    Industrial & consumer product designPCB design & layout
    8 chapters

  • The Hardware Entrepreneur · 28m

    #046 - When not to start a startup - how to license your idea (Part 2), with Stephen Key of inventRight, USA

    Stephen Key of inventRight explains how inventors can license ideas using a Provisional Patent Application (PPA) instead of launching a startup, arguing that PPAs provide sufficient protection against copycats in fast-moving markets. He details the steps for writing a strong PPA, including conducting prior art searches and defining unique points of difference, while warning against relying solely on patent attorneys who may have financial conflicts of interest. Key also shares lessons from his career, such as the importance of working for startups early on and using non-disclosure agreements when seeking external help to avoid co-ownership disputes.

    Intellectual propertyStarting a product company
    8 chapters

  • Making It · 1h 05m

    Episode 280: It’s great to have a few extra brains around

    Jimmy Diresta, Bob Clagett, and David Picciuto discuss the complexities of intellectual property, with Diresta detailing his trademark enforcement against a name-squatting site and his patent search for a mask invention. The hosts also cover Diresta's upcoming trip to Hollywood to film 'Making It', Picciuto's woodworking projects including a video on miter joints, and Clagett's restart of his 'BITS' series. They conclude with recommendations for the Center for Art in Wood, Lars Christensen's Fusion 360 tutorials, and the Unmade podcast.

    Intellectual propertyEDA & CAD tools
    9 chapters

The summary, chapters and topics are generated from the episode’s audio by this directory, not written by Designing in the Wild. The episode itself belongs to its publisher.