Hardware Podcasts

Ep. 24 - Open Hardware Licenses ft. Thea Flowers

Open Hardware Manufacturing Podcast · 11 Jul 2024 · 1h 25m

What this episode covers

Thea Flowers, president of the Open Source Hardware Association, explains the spectrum of open hardware licensing, ranging from public domain to strongly reciprocal (copyleft) models. She details how copyright, patents, and specific licenses like CERN OHL, MIT, and GPL interact, emphasizing the legal concept of separability between hardware designs and firmware. The discussion highlights the importance of choosing licenses that match project goals, such as using permissive licenses for broad adoption versus reciprocal licenses for public utilities, and warns that legal enforcement often depends on resources rather than just the license text.

Most relevant to

early-stage companies

Topics

Mentioned

Companies
Open Source Hardware Association
Also
CERN OHL, MIT license, Apache license, GPL, Creative Commons, choosealicense.com, TLDRLegal

Related episodes from other shows

Other shows on the same ground, closest first.

  • Embedded.fm · 1h 14m

    289: Stamping HORSE on Zebras

    Alicia Gibb, executive director of the Open Source Hardware Association (OSHW) and director of the Blow Things Up Lab at the University of Colorado Boulder, discusses the legal and business frameworks of open source hardware. She explains how OSHW uses trademark certification to ensure quality and prevent misuse, contrasting this with the limitations of copyright and patent laws in the US. Gibb details her experience manufacturing Build Upons, light-up LEGO-compatible bricks, highlighting the extreme difficulty of sourcing manufacturers capable of meeting Lego's tight tolerances. She argues that open source hardware can coexist with profitable business models by leveraging brand trust, speed to market, and community-driven innovation rather than relying on IP monopolies.

    Intellectual propertyDesign for manufacturing & NPI
    8 chapters

  • Making It · 48m

    Episode 020: Open source ideas

    Jimmy Diresta, Bob Clagett, and David Picciuto discuss the nuances of inspiration versus copying in the maker community, debating when taking ideas is flattery versus theft. They explore open-source principles by comparing software licenses to hardware brands like Arduino, and examine how attribution and scale affect the ethics of replicating designs. The hosts also share updates on their current projects, including Diresta's distillery video and Clagett's transition to full-time content creation.

    Intellectual propertyCreator business
    7 chapters

  • Embedded.fm · 50m

    45: Yanking on a Cat's Tail Is the Only Way to Learn

    Dave Anders, who works for CircuitCo, the manufacturer of the BeagleBone Black and MinnowBoard, discusses the nuances of open source hardware, contrasting fully open designs with 'open source friendly' products like the Flyswatter 2. He explains how CircuitCo manages production scaling for the BeagleBone Black to meet OEM demand and details the transition of the MinnowBoard to a 100% open hardware model in partnership with Intel. Anders also covers the business models of open hardware, noting that while tools like the original Flyswatter were fully open, later iterations restrict fabrication files to prevent poor-quality clones while still allowing software development.

    Open-source hardwarePCB design & layout
    9 chapters

  • The Amp Hour · 59m

    Open Hardware and The Creative Economy

    Dave Jones of EEVblog and Chris Gammell discuss the definition of open source hardware, arguing that excluding non-commercial Creative Commons licenses unfairly disadvantages small creators against large kit manufacturers like SparkFun and Farnell. They analyze the rise of Samsung as a semiconductor competitor to Intel and the brain drain of talent from the US to Asia. Jones also provides a glowing review of the Amazon Kindle 3, praising its E-ink display and battery life, while criticizing the EE Store and Silverbrook Research for their lack of tangible products despite heavy funding.

    Open-source hardwarePolicy, trade & tariffs
    6 chapters

  • The Amp Hour · 1h 12m

    Kickstarter, Manufacturing, Open Hardware - Judging Jurisdictional Junctures

    Guest Jeff Kaiser, a hardware engineer at Valve, joins hosts Chris Gammell and Dave Jones to discuss the intersection of open hardware and crowdfunding. The group analyzes MakerBot's controversial decision to close-source parts of the Replicator 2, debating the legal implications of share-alike licenses and the role of venture capital in open-source hardware companies. They also examine Kickstarter's new rules requiring real prototypes and risk disclosures, using the LIFX smart bulb as a case study for vaporware and the challenges of manufacturing complex electronics.

    Crowdfunding & preordersOpen-source hardware
    5 chapters

The summary, chapters and topics are generated from the episode’s audio by this directory, not written by Open Hardware Manufacturing Podcast. The episode itself belongs to its publisher.