Hardware Podcasts

Episode 020: Open source ideas

Making It · 8 May 2015 · 48m

What this episode covers

Jimmy Diresta, Bob Clagett, and David Picciuto discuss the nuances of inspiration versus copying in the maker community, debating when taking ideas is flattery versus theft. They explore open-source principles by comparing software licenses to hardware brands like Arduino, and examine how attribution and scale affect the ethics of replicating designs. The hosts also share updates on their current projects, including Diresta's distillery video and Clagett's transition to full-time content creation.

Most relevant to

early-stage companies

Topics

Mentioned

Companies
Arduino, DeWalt, Quicksilver, IKEA, Core 77
Products
WordPress
Also
Cook with Meat, Homemade Modern, Steve Ramsey, Izzy Swan, Casey Neistat, Chamberlain, Make: Fair

Related episodes from other shows

Other shows on the same ground, closest first.

  • The Amp Hour · 1h 00m

    Analog Components, First Person Flying and Idea Ownership

    Hosts Dave Jones and Chris Gammell discuss the open-source chip design software Electric and the MOSIS fabrication service, noting the high costs and specialized nature of custom silicon. They analyze the business model of Instructables, criticizing its requirement for user registration to access open-source project files, and debate the ethics of employment contracts that claim ownership of employees' personal ideas. The episode concludes with a technical discussion on analog components, emphasizing the educational value of operational block diagrams in data sheets from companies like Linear Technology and Texas Instruments.

    Open-source hardwareChips, FPGAs & semiconductors
    7 chapters

  • The Amp Hour · 1h 05m

    Shonky Stiver Stultiloquence

    Hosts Chris Gammell and Dave Jones discuss the economic impact of credit downgrades on startups and the tension between the DIY maker movement's growth and its original ethos, citing Wired articles and companies like Adafruit and SparkFun. Jones rants about Pinguino boards from Olimex for claiming open hardware status while withholding schematic and PCB files, highlighting a broader issue of 'open source washing.' The episode concludes with a review of a fraudulent car fuel saver device, a history segment on physicist Sir Neville Mott, and a discussion on Scott Adams' views regarding boredom and creativity.

    Open-source hardwareValidation & product-market fit
    7 chapters

  • Embedded.fm · 50m

    45: Yanking on a Cat's Tail Is the Only Way to Learn

    Dave Anders, who works for CircuitCo, the manufacturer of the BeagleBone Black and MinnowBoard, discusses the nuances of open source hardware, contrasting fully open designs with 'open source friendly' products like the Flyswatter 2. He explains how CircuitCo manages production scaling for the BeagleBone Black to meet OEM demand and details the transition of the MinnowBoard to a 100% open hardware model in partnership with Intel. Anders also covers the business models of open hardware, noting that while tools like the original Flyswatter were fully open, later iterations restrict fabrication files to prevent poor-quality clones while still allowing software development.

    Open-source hardwarePCB design & layout
    9 chapters

  • Embedded.fm · 1h 14m

    289: Stamping HORSE on Zebras

    Alicia Gibb, executive director of the Open Source Hardware Association (OSHW) and director of the Blow Things Up Lab at the University of Colorado Boulder, discusses the legal and business frameworks of open source hardware. She explains how OSHW uses trademark certification to ensure quality and prevent misuse, contrasting this with the limitations of copyright and patent laws in the US. Gibb details her experience manufacturing Build Upons, light-up LEGO-compatible bricks, highlighting the extreme difficulty of sourcing manufacturers capable of meeting Lego's tight tolerances. She argues that open source hardware can coexist with profitable business models by leveraging brand trust, speed to market, and community-driven innovation rather than relying on IP monopolies.

    Intellectual propertyDesign for manufacturing & NPI
    8 chapters

  • The Amp Hour · 1h 16m

    Can't We All Just Get Arduino? - Tardiloquent Trademark Tirade

    Hosts Dave Jones and Chris Gammell discuss the legal battle between Arduino LLC and co-founder Gianluca Martino over the Arduino trademark, analyzing the implications for open source hardware. They also explore the challenges of portable test equipment design, the rise of browser-based mechanical CAD tools like Onshape, and the importance of educational software licensing.

    Intellectual propertyEDA & CAD tools
    6 chapters

The summary, chapters and topics are generated from the episode’s audio by this directory, not written by Making It. The episode itself belongs to its publisher.