Making It #012: Handmade?

Making It · 12 Mar 2015 · 32m

What this episode covers

Jimmy Diresta, Bob Clagett, and David Picciuto discuss the tension between handmade craftsmanship and computer-controlled manufacturing, specifically using CNC machines and 3D printers. They debate whether using tools like the X-Carve, Shapeoko, and vinyl cutters diminishes the value of 'handmade' goods, concluding that the maker movement democratizes production and allows for hybrid workflows that combine machine precision with hand-finishing. The hosts highlight how accessible technology empowers new entrepreneurs and changes consumer expectations, while acknowledging that traditional crafts like boat building remain distinct from this new paradigm.

Mentioned

Companies
Inventables, Dremel
Tools
X-Carve, Shapeoko, Shape Ocho 2, Silhouette Bob, VCarve
Also
South by Southwest

Other shows on the same ground, closest first.

  • The Amp Hour · 1h 18m

    Shifting Away From DIY - Pedetentious PnP Progress

    Chris Gammell of Contextual Electronics and Dave Jones of EEV Blog discuss the shifting landscape of hardware development, moving from DIY hobbyism to professional manufacturing. They review Maker Faire exhibits, including Volterra circuit printers, Cartesian Co routers, and various pick-and-place machines, debating their practical utility. The hosts analyze the impact of new software tools like Altium's CircuitMaker and the rising cost of components, arguing that while entry-level hardware is becoming commoditized, professional board design and manufacturing remain essential for successful products.

  • Shop Talk Live · 57m

    STL354: Go and Do the Thing

    Erik Curtis, a furniture maker and YouTuber based in Philadelphia, joins Shop Talk Live to discuss the realities of running a woodworking business, teaching, and creating content. Curtis and hosts Amanda and Vic explore the myth of the solitary furniture maker, arguing that modern makers must diversify through teaching, writing, and media to sustain their craft. They debate the role of YouTube in woodworking, distinguishing between entertainment-focused channels and those that provide substantive technical education, while addressing the accessibility of high-end tools versus the necessity of skill. The conversation also covers design philosophy, emphasizing the importance of grain selection, proportion, and stripping away excessive ornamentation to achieve clear, functional aesthetics.

  • Shop Talk Live · 1h 04m

    Shop Talk Live 11: That Sinking Feeling

    Fine Woodworking editors Asa Christiana, Mike Pekovich, and Ed Pirnik discuss the evolution of woodworking styles, debating whether the craft is repeating past movements or finding a new identity through reclaimed materials and handmade authenticity. They evaluate the value of boutique hand tools like Lee Valley and Holty planes versus standard high-end options, and provide practical advice on pricing custom work, selecting the correct wood glue types, and sharpening techniques for hand planes. The episode concludes with the editors sharing specific building blunders, including routing errors and measurement mistakes, and how they repaired them.

  • Shop Talk Live · 1h 05m

    STL273: Shaper Origin—Then and Now

    Joe Hebenstreit, CEO of Shaper, and Adi Rao, Product Lead at Shaper, discuss the evolution of Shaper Origin from its early prototyping days to its current ecosystem of hardware and software. They detail the development of Shaper Studio, a simplified digital design tool for craftspeople, and Plate, a precision jig that blends analog woodworking techniques with digital tracking. The conversation highlights Shaper's philosophy of augmenting human skill rather than replacing it, targeting both experienced woodworkers and digital natives.

  • Embedded.fm · 1h 18m

    160: Chowdered up the Spoilboard

    Daniel Hienzsch, resident engineer at SupplyFrame's Pasadena Design Lab, and Majenta Strongheart, an industrial design student from the School of the Art Institute of Chicago, discuss the operation of a maker space and advice for home makers. They detail the specific tools available in the lab, including ShopBot CNC routers, OtherMill PCB mills, and various 3D printers, while contrasting their reliability and utility. The conversation covers the challenges of maintaining equipment, the decision to use whiteboards over digital tools for project management, and recommendations for building a home workshop on a budget.

The summary, chapters and topics are generated from the episode’s audio by this directory, not written by Making It. The episode itself belongs to its publisher.