Risks of using generative AI in product design - IDology #17

IDology · 5 Mar 2024 · 38m · Episode 17

AI in practice: 3 real uses of AI described

What this episode covers

Rafał Piłat, co-founder of Mindsailors, and Jakub Zarzyński, a computational designer at Mindsailors, discuss the integration of generative AI into industrial design workflows. They argue that tools like Midjourney and Stable Diffusion are valuable for rapid ideation and automating sketching but warn against ethical pitfalls regarding copyright and the risk of homogenized design trends. The guests emphasize that AI output is not a substitute for professional manufacturing-ready design and urge designers to adapt to these technologies to remain competitive.

AI in practice

Where this conversation describes AI being used to build or deliver a product. Part of the AI in practice tracker.

DesignMidjourney

The team used Midjourney to create mood boards for clients, integrating AI-generated images with traditional inspiration sources to enhance the visual presentation of design concepts.

“we've been using midjourney and stable diffusion for uh, for different projects. Uh, we spend a lot of time on using both uh, both software. So, uh, we pretty much know a lot of their limitations and we've learned where, when in our design process, we can, uh, we can use it, uh, so it benefits us and it's not just a novelty or a gimmick.”

Speaker 2 · Hear it at 25:28

DesignStable Diffusion

The team used Stable Diffusion to transform semi-realistic renders of people or characters into photorealistic images by applying control nets, improving the realism and quality of visual outputs for client presentations.

“And we use it to make, uh, to transform our, let's say, uh, semi-realistic renders of people or characters into photorealistic persons, and this is a great workflow, which takes uh, our uh, work, um, even uh, a lever all to uh, up in terms of uh, the quality or uh, realism when it comes to uh, to people uh, visible in the in the pictures.”

Speaker 3 · Hear it at 27:12

DesignChatGPT

The team uses ChatGPT as a research tool to assist with information gathering and ideation, treating it as a helpful alternative to standard search engines for specific design queries.

“I guess we can obviously start with the chat GPT because it's helpful. It's like an I don't want to say alternative to Google, but it's pretty much helpful whenever you are doing any research. Maybe not uh, it is not so important for the visual style of uh, visual aspect, but apart from that, uh, we've been using midjourney and stable diffusion for uh, for different projects.”

Speaker 2 · Hear it at 25:28

Mentioned

Companies
Reddit, OpenAI
Tools
ChatGPT, Midjourney, Stable Diffusion, Pinterest, SolidWorks, Blender

Other shows on the same ground, closest first.

  • It's Only a Prototype · 53m

    How AI Is Transforming Product Design

    Industrial designer and AI consultant Rupert Warries joins hosts Tom Constable and Phil Staunton to discuss how generative AI is transforming product design workflows. Warries explains how tools like Vizcom and ComfyUI allow designers to accelerate ideation and 3D rendering while managing stakeholder expectations regarding the realism of AI outputs. The conversation covers the legal ambiguities of AI training data, the risk of over-reliance on AI as a 'crutch', and the future impact of AI on design roles and hiring practices.

  • EMS@C-LEVEL · 22m

    Revolutionizing Everything, Even Manufacturing: The Transformative Power of AI with Emily Laird

    Emily Laird, an AI integration technologist and host of the Generative AI 101 podcast, discusses how generative AI is transforming manufacturing by making historical data actionable for predictive maintenance and demand forecasting. She draws parallels between fast fashion and manufacturing, highlighting how AI accelerates design cycles and material efficiency through rapid prototyping and 3D modeling. Laird emphasizes the necessity of combining AI literacy with deep domain knowledge, arguing that AI acts as a co-pilot to preserve tribal knowledge and enable specialized roles rather than replacing human workers.

  • Designing in the Wild · 1h 01m

    Industrial Design, AI & the Business of Design with Jordan Nollman | S3E02

    Jordan Nollman, founder and CEO of Sprout, a Boston-based multidisciplinary design consultancy, discusses the evolution of industrial design from a solo practice to a 60-person studio offering strategy, branding, UX, and engineering. He details the business realities of running a consultancy, including the critical importance of retainers, the pitfalls of all-equity deals, and the strategic use of AI tools like VizCom to accelerate storyboarding and visualization without replacing core design thinking. Nollman emphasizes that while AI speeds up execution, the value lies in solving real-world problems, citing projects like a microplastics sensor and a solar-powered milk trolley that balance aesthetics, function, and sustainability.

  • The Builder Circle · 1h 13m

    S3 E5: AI in Hardware: The Future of Design, Manufacturing, and Innovation with Kristen Edwards

    Kristen Edwards, CTO and co-founder of Pensa Technologies and MIT PhD candidate, discusses integrating AI into hardware engineering workflows, emphasizing the need to track decision reasoning and manage data governance. She explains that while AI acts as a 'co-pilot' to augment human expertise, high-consequence tasks require human oversight due to liability and explainability concerns. Edwards highlights specific challenges in spatial reasoning, design-for-manufacturing translation, and IP security, suggesting techniques like federated learning and retrieval-augmented generation to protect sensitive engineering data. The conversation covers practical applications in CAD, automated testing, and quality assurance, noting that AI will likely replace repetitive tasks rather than creative engineering roles.

  • Making It · 1h 08m

    392: We Can Design Our Way Out of This

    Jimmy Diresta, Bob Clagett, and David Picciuto discuss the nature of creativity, debating whether new ideas exist or if everything is a remix of prior work, using examples like the Pika Screw and AI-generated code. Bob Clagett details his progress on building a rowboat and a humorous 'fart chair' project using an Arduino and methane sensor, while Jimmy Diresta announces the launch of his 'Arduino For Makers' online course. The hosts also explore how AI tools like ChatGPT are being used to write code and enhance photos, concluding that iteration and giving credit to inspirations are key to the maker community.

The summary, chapters and topics are generated from the episode’s audio by this directory, not written by IDology. The episode itself belongs to its publisher.